Campus chalkings blur the line of free speech and hate speech
More stories from Editorial
What began as a nationwide trend of labeling Trump-supporting messages in chalk throughout college grounds has spiraled into a debate over free or hate speech on Marshall University’s campus.
Dan Scavino, social media director of the Trump campaign, posted a photo of a pro-Trump hashtag on the side of a Huntington student rental house—complete with a Marshall flag—and a brief praise for the students’ support. In chalk, the message read, “Trump 2016 #BuildTheWall,” in reference to Donald Trump’s desire to construct a physical barrier between the United States and Mexico to prevent illegal immigration.
Marshall president Jerry Gilbert responded to the situation immediately and Physical Plant employees were tasked with scrubbing writings from the walls and pouring water on the walkways to remove the chalk.
The workers, however, could not wash away the aftertaste left behind by the situation.
By Monday, Gilbert issued a statement acknowledging the political messages and each student’s free speech protections under the First Amendment, but warned that any discriminatory behavior would not be tolerated.
“At Marshall, we welcome and embrace all members of our university and local community, regardless of their national origin, race, color, sex, sexual orientation, religion, veteran status or disabilities,” Gilbert said. “We have no walls around our university and it is an open access campus.”
On Tuesday morning, the words, “Am I in your safe space?” were written along the exterior of Jenkins Hall; placed conveniently near the sidewalks lined with red flags placed to raise awareness for campus sexual assault.
Although no known connections can be made between the Trump chalk and “safe space” chalk, students quickly took to social media to express their discomfort.
“This is near the red flags set out for sexual assault awareness month, symbols for people who need safe spaces, especially on college campuses,” said senior Nathan Full. “For the record: Yes, you are in my safe space, jackasses.”
“In a school with a thriving study abroad program and with so many international students, that’s so distasteful,” junior, Alex Runyon posted. “Advocate for your candidate, but don’t make people feel like they’re not wanted here.”
Marshall University may be home to a small herd of anonymous Trump-backing chalk-artists, but it is also home to a large community of international students, specifically groups of students of various religions and ethnicities Trump has threatened to deport, monitor or remove if he’s elected into the Oval Office.
A fine line exists between free speech and hate speech, which is characterized by the American Bar Association as speech that “offends, threatens or insults groups, based on race, color, religion, national origin, disability or other traits.”
The difference? Human decency.
Your donation will help continue the work of independent student journalism at Marshall University. If you benefit from The Parthenon's free content, please consider making a donation.
Robert Martin • Apr 7, 2016 at 1:39 pm
Please tell the truth.In our world today a large number of people are ready to die and kill other people if they do not say and do ad they are told.These People who are members of Islam believe that the Quaran is the living word of Allah. They are true believers that all True Muslims must spread the word of Allah by any and all means
Anyone who does not snbmit and join is a infindeil and must be dealt with including death.These Muslims are ready to kill any who will not convert to Islam.You can not talk or reason with these people they know that Allah is God and calls for them to bring Islam to all the people of the World.You must make your own choice. Convert or fight for your own beliefs. This is the truth and if you think that this is made up ask any non Muslim from Iraqi or Syria or Iran.These Muslims behead Jews Christian’s Amy one who is non Muslim people.. We in America must be ready for what is coming.Fight or Die.
yoonis kapor • Apr 7, 2016 at 12:36 pm
How dare these fascists try to shut down the students right to campaign for whomever they want!
I can’t believe the schools administration allows these brownshirts to shout down differing opinions.
Richard Saul • Apr 7, 2016 at 2:53 am
There is no “fine line”- we have no ” hate speech” laws in this country. It’s ALL free speech.
jake cox • Apr 6, 2016 at 11:43 pm
Was commenting on the writes Facebook pages about how safe spaces is not got for the first amendment, she blocked me lol guess she only likes one sided storys
Christopher Gonzales • Apr 6, 2016 at 1:50 pm
I would like to be the first one to say that this is not a big deal. As a population of students we all should just continue our daily routines and not worry about something drawn on the sidewalk. This was blown completely out of proportion
JC • Apr 6, 2016 at 11:37 pm
This isn’t a big deal to you because this is not affecting you. Are you a sexual assault victim? If the answer is no, you have no say. Are you a Muslim or any part of the group Trump wants to deport? If the answer is wrong, you have no say. You do not have the privilege of telling those less privileged than you that they don’t get to be offended.
John Doe • Apr 11, 2016 at 11:28 am
Why don’t you take you hate speech towards people with differing opinions than you somewhere else. This entire newspaper lately has been filled with opinion and jargon, mostly false, and has been a disgrace to the university. This newspaper upholds ZERO journalistic standards, doesn’t bother fact checking themselves, and their opinion commentary, particularly this article, are essentially a made up fairy tale! If you all cannot handle chalk writing on a sidewalk, DROP OUT OF COLLEGE, because in the real world, you’ll have much worse things said and done to you than a campaign message written in chalk on a sidewalk! Finally, I think that the parthenon’s hate speech towards those who hold differing views and opinions than themselves and their efforts to shut it down is disgraceful, and if anybody should be shut down, it should be the abysmal parthenon!