EDITORIAL: Whitney Cummings doesn’t deserve W.Va.
In case you missed it, last week comedian Whitney Cummings appeared on The Late Late Show with James Corden. Cummings discussed with the TV show host, as well as fellow guest Bradley Whitford, what she claims is her Appalachian heritage in a painful and cheap segment, which was done in incredibly poor taste.
Among other things too disappointing to name, Cummings, who wasn’t even born here but spent summers at Harpers Ferry, recounted that her father always told her he was from the western part of Virginia. Imagine her surprise when she discovered he was actually born in West Virginia, and let the jokes begin.
“I’m basically first generation like Appalachia, full on like hillbilly,” Cummings said with a sour look on her face. “I just found out that that’s my heritage, and a lot of things are starting to make sense.”
Instead of embracing her heritage, the comedian wrote terrible jokes about our state to relay to James Corden, who was unfamiliar with West Virginia. Now, unfortunately, his only impression of us comes from someone who isn’t from here and doesn’t understand who we are.
And who knows how many guests and viewers now have that same image of West Virginia in their minds. Cummings should not have introduced our state like that, spreading hateful and untrue stereotypes that West Virginians themselves have for so long tried to overcome.
One of her jokes dealt with “hillbilly DNA,” something that suggests earlier settlers of the region fended off bears with our personalities. It’s too bad we can’t fend her off. Also, being “crazy” by her definition has nothing to do with where you’re from. It’s something you develop from a lack of compassion.
Comedy has a history of punching up those in power. On this TV appearance, Cummings chose to punch down the powerless, in this case the people of West Virginia who couldn’t defend themselves against her rants. She has a national platform that she could have used to disprove stereotypes, or just spread some love. It’s possible to still do that in a humorous way.
Perhaps what makes this situation worse is Cummings’ responses to the backlash she received. Many people on social media called out Cummings, stating how disappointed they were. In a few blanket responses, the comedian wrote “All love,” and the clip was taken down.
But in a separate tweet, she stated, “We are at a point where we demand apologies we would never dream of accepting.”
Maybe she simply shouldn’t have made fun of those who have no way of standing up for themselves and spread love instead of hate to begin with.
It’s no wonder Cummings’ father didn’t tell her that he was from the Mountain State. She simply didn’t deserve to know, and he realized it. West Virginians, please believe that she doesn’t deserve us, our hospitality and our beautiful scenery.
So, while Cummings continues to explore her “hillbilly DNA,” let us remind ourselves what’s in our West Virginia roots and heritage: forgiveness.
Your donation will help continue the work of independent student journalism at Marshall University. If you benefit from The Parthenon's free content, please consider making a donation.
Julia Damron • Oct 21, 2019 at 4:46 pm
I was married to a man from west virginia .he was the best that ever happened to me. We moved to west virginia and I met the most wonderful people there .I have inlaws there and .any friends .these people may be from a mountain state and are people who work hard to survive. They work the coal mines so you can heat your home .yes they are called hillbillies but they are wo derful loving people .how dare you put these people down you email stupid person .west virginia will not ever welcome you there .john Denver wrote a song of west Virginia and it says mountain. Reaches the sky ,and blue waters ,mountain momma. Theses mountains reach the sky .and are beautiful .ask broad paisley, Jennifer GRner ,steve hardly etc.dont come here.you are not welcome .
lillie Bailey • Oct 21, 2019 at 9:45 am
I am from Kentucky and for this so called comedian to say what she did about West Virginia and Appalachia in general, makes my blood boil. First of all, I have never heard of her, so that tells me that she isn’t much of a comedian. We in Appalachia are so blessed to live here, beautiful land, good people, clean air and we don’t have to put up with trash like Cummings, we are too good for her.
Lillie Bailey
Marsha Timpson • Oct 19, 2019 at 4:26 pm
To paraphrase my 5 year old granddaughter, “How Dare You!” Don’t worry Whitney — not one speck of your “hillbilly roots” have come through. In West Virginia we believe in graciousness and kindness and I do not believe you have any of those traits in your DNA.
I had never heard of you before this show and most likely, I will not hear of you in the future. If someone belittles others in such a crass, demeaning manner THEY have a problem. If you have to tear others down to build yourself up you will never be successful.
And shame on you James Corden for promoting such garbage.
Hopefully, Jennifer Garner never sees this or she will go off on you. She is a proud ambassador for the state she was raised in.
Teresa Chance • Oct 19, 2019 at 9:15 am
If she truly had our DNA then she would know better. Home brewed is always better than an imported fake.
Helen Davis • Oct 18, 2019 at 1:05 pm
When I saw the clip living in West Virginia I was clearly upset about the remarks she made, West Virginia is a beautiful state and our people are wonderful, when something goes wrong we are there for each other. West Virginia has so many wonderful places to visit, beautiful parks, in Autumn the trees are spectacular, before you spout off about some place, visit here and see what we have to offer, West by God Virginia.Take me home country roads.
Neal • Oct 17, 2019 at 11:15 am
Ms. Cummings is a spoiled little rich brat! The only thing she can do is poke fun of really people or maybe her uneducated thoughts of the way people should be in her mind. She is completely ignorant of the real American and how they live.
Phil Kerbawy • Oct 16, 2019 at 7:19 pm
I’m going to have to STRONGLY disagree with this column writer. I’m not the least bit offended personally. Who gives a f**k?! They’re jokes. They’re not real. I STILL make West Virginia jokes based off the untrue stereotypes (MOSTLY untrue 😉). There’s a metric sh*t-ton of better things to get upset about than a comedian’s jokes about ANYTHING! I don’t care what the topic is. I’m pretty sure we’ve chuckled at catholic priest jokes, Michael Jackson jokes, and God knows what other f*cked up sh*t happens in REAL LIFE. Guess what? That means we laughed at pedophilia, rape, and who knows whatever else. Preeeeetty sure some West Virginia hillbilly stereotypes aren’t far from the truth at some point or another. Sure it could be plenty of other states, because they have similar stereotypes, but it’s ours, and I’m fairly dubious as to the amount of people that actually TRULY BELIEVE that the stereotypes are true. I’m a native West Virginian, and I had a shirt made up (that I proudly wear every chance I get, because it’s f*cking hilarious to others AS WELL AS MYSELF), that was graciously printed up BY a West Virginian (because the retail store that originally had this shirt stopped selling it), that exclaims inside an outline of our wild and wonderful state, “IT’S ALL RELATIVE IN WEST VIRGINIA”. Maybe it’s not that she doesn’t deserve our state, maybe it’s that some of us easily offended over nothing need to get over ourselves, because they definitely don’t deserve her and her brand of comedy… C O M E D Y. Laugh motherf*ckers.
Just my opinion.
Phillbilly